what we are and what we eat – an evening with jonathan safran foer

On Saturday night, right in the middle of a fairly miserable long weekend, I dragged a semi-interested David to the Opera House for the annual Festival of Dangerous Ideas. The speaker? Jonathan Safran Foer, author of Eating Animals (as well as two novels, Everything is Illuminated and Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close).

I read Eating Animals a couple of months ago and thought it was great. Safran Foer has a way with storytelling which made the book so much more than a fact-based vegetarian diatribe. This kind of even-keeled rationality carried into his discussion with the Opera House audience. While his stance is clearly “pro-vegetarian” (and while Eating Animals was similarly working towards such a forgone conclusion), he was in no way a sanctimonious, preachy git or a raging, hate filled vegan (don’t get me wrong, I know some amazing vegans, but some are blatantly batshit insane). Instead, he relied on the numbers and the facts to speak for themselves. 99% of meat in the USA is factory farmed. Over 95% in the European Union. Americans eat 180 times more chicken per year than they did a year ago. The number one factor in climate change is meat consumption. Smithfield, the largest pork producer in the USA, had 7000 violations of the Clean Water Act in one year.

In addition to the facts, that were slowly but surely guilting half the audience, he also talked about the language and the discourse of our relationship with food, specifically meat. One of the things that struck me most was his comment (heavily paraphrased!): ‘We need to eat less meat. We cannot expect everyone to go vegetarian, but we can expect everyone to eat less meat. For me, less meat happens to be no meat. For writers like Mark Bittman, it means being vegan until 5pm. Think of each meal as an opportunity to make a choice‘ I liked that sense of flexibility, that avoidance of labels that means that one meal with meat does not mean that we have fallen off the wagon, that we must berate ourselves for failure.

One way or another, it was a good enough talk that my avowedly omnivorous partner is speaking of reducing his own meat consumption, If you ever have the chance to see Safran Foer speak, or if you can get hold of a copy of Eating Animals, I would definitely recommend it.

For an interesting review of Eating Animals, I’d recommend this article by Peter Singer in The Monthly


One thought on “what we are and what we eat – an evening with jonathan safran foer

  1. “I like that sense of flexibility…”

    So do I! I don’t like how conversations about, for example, eating less meat will be met with comments like “Well, we can’t all be vegetarians!!!”. No, but that isn’t the point. Not everything has to be an extreme. It’s about making sacrifices, all of us, so that our way of life can continue. And it can definitely start with eating less meat.

    Have you ever watched the movie Food Inc? I showed it to my students. They were pretty grossed out by the factory farming : )

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s